Pantheism and Catholicism: The Fateful Encounter
One of the few things Alexis de Tocqueville most underrated was the affinity in contemporary times between Catholicism and pantheism. I know this may be a revolting and outrageous idea, or allegation, to a fair number of friends and/or readers. But I have thought it over and have decided to move forward with it. For now I can only point you to The Immanent Frame, specifically to William Connolly's brief for pantheism (though he doesn't call it this), one of the plainest, frankest, and 'best' (yes, because it's Nietzschean) that I've seen in a while.
My main concern is that Taylor, and Catholics like him, are inclined to cede vast amounts of territory to the main thrusts and attitudes of the pantheist creed -- most importantly, the holiness of all love, in all its physicality, as an immanent and transcendent experience of peaceful yet powerful becoming in time -- as long as the Church and the Nicene Creed are kept intact. For at least a handful of Protestants, this amounts to something resembling worst nightmare territory. For what it's worth.

I just don't see the link between Catholicism and pantheism. Could you elaborate beyond a review of Taylor? Intriguing concept, but one that is far from established.
Posted by:Kevin | April 21, 2008 at 10:08 PM
I don't say it to offend, but I've always seen the Nicene Creed quite pantheistic.
Posted by:egg shells | April 22, 2008 at 06:19 PM